I had decided a while ago that I wouldn't post reviews of all of the restaurants I visit in NYC. But while I do like to keep this site focused on documenting my own cooking, I would be remiss if not mentioning who, what and where influences how I cook in my own kitchen.
Every few weeks I will give a list of recommendations based on the recent dining experiences I've had. I have started to find newspaper restaurant reviews really boring (but thankfully they are giving us Jules) so don't expect long winded BS for these recos - I'll just cut straight to the food.
Recommended, You'll love it
Blue Ribbon proper - This continues to be one of my favorites restaurants in the city. I go here when I need a great meal. Period. Steak tartar, clam stew for two, oysters with perfect mignonette (a rarity in my opinion), fried chicken, skate, OK stop. Great vibe, perfect date restaurant.
Biltmore Room - Expensive but worth it. Very focused flavors but a bit playful wit
h the menu. Nice dining room, good bar, has a Babbo feel to me in the fact that it's high end, ambitious cooking without the formality you'd get at a 4 star restaurant. Chef Gary Robbins kicked his status up a notch with the birth of this gem. He should get recognition as one of the best chefs in the city.
Uno Pizza Napoletana - So damn good. Just be cool with paying double for a pizza before you go and you'll love it. I really wish this place was BYOB, because I'd like to drink something other than an average beer or the low priority wine options. I'd bring a sixer of an amber beer or a Malbec from Argentina, as the awesome wood burning oven flavor is great for a big wine.
Little Giant - Just love this little place. So homegrown feeling, as if you were in the first restaurant of a young, ambitious team. And you are! Nice wine list (but don't like the stemless bistro style wine glasses I've had there a few times. I really believe wines need a bowl style wine glass for maximum pleasure, but just ask and they'll give you a proper wine glass). Great vibe, friendly staff, simple and nicely done food based on whatever is fresh and in the markets.
Neptune Room - everything I wrote here continues to be true after repeat visits.
Recommended.....but
Les Halles - Hadn't been to my old stomping grounds for a while until recently. Saturday night service beyond bad. Food is still tasting the same, which is nothing short of rich, over the top, old school bistro French meal. Meats continue to be what to order. Fries = excellent. Onion soup still as good as when it was a craveable winter brunch order throughout my just-out-of-college days.
Cookshop - Uneven. Thin and unremarkable clam chowder. Fresh, beautifully crisp cod over chickpeas. Great wood oven items ala older sister Five Points, like razor clams and wood roasted pasta. Nice vibe. If feeling untrendy, I would reco Red Cat for similar style fare that is better and more consistent, in my opinion.
Babbo - Molto is my favorite celeb chef, no doubt about it. I have also considered Babbo one of my favs for the past - what - 7 years. But recently the beef cheek ravioli wasn't up to previous high standards (overcooked) and our bronzino was just average (fishy,soggy). Clams in chili broth, always very good. Two fantastic wine choices by the staff. I personally think they need to update the menu beyond the Babbo classics to refresh and shake things up a bit. It's just missing its old spark. I wonder if the eye is on a bigger price with Del Posto, but I hope not.
The Jury's Still Out On....
Chanterelle - Very good food, don't get me wrong. And definitely worthy of a star from the wankers
at Michelin. But it is clearly aiming at being 3-4 star Times restaurant (just have a look at your bill at the end of the meal) and it has achieved these excellent ratings in the past. I think it is a restaurant to watch, as I think the issues need to be addressed - surely the team must have been taken aback by the lack of a Michelin star. Such a diss surely must make you evaulate things a bit. In my opinion, the restaurant is missing the wow experience you'd expect at these prices. Excellent wine list (a few bottles I was interested in were over 100% mark up from retail research I've done since eating here - ugh). Seafood sausage is an ace. Cheese course - not sure I can name a better one. Lots of big, thick, meaty, over-reduced sauces overwhelmed many of the entrees.